The Challenge: Battle of the Seasons

Battle of the Seasons
Season 23
Presented by	T. J. Lavin
No. of contestants	32
Winners	Ashley Kelsey Frank Sweeney Sam McGinn Zach Nichols
Location	Bodrum, Turkey Swakopmund & Windhoek, Namibia
No. of episodes	13 (Reunion Included)
Release
Original network	MTV
Original release	September 19 (2012-09-19) – December 19, 2012 (2012-12-19)
Season chronology
← Previous Battle of the Exes Next → Rivals II

The Challenge: Battle of the Seasons is the 23rd season of the MTV reality game show, The Challenge. Although the season shares the same name as the show's fifth season, Battle of the Seasons, unlike other sequel seasons, the season is not distinguished as part "II" as it has a completely different format. The season took place in Bodrum, Turkey and Swakopmund & Windhoek, Namibia.

Former casts from select seasons of MTV's The Real World and The Challenge competed with the hopes of winning a piece of the $250,000 grand prize.^[1] This is the first season since season 12 that does not include any cast members from The Real World: Key West.

The season premiered with a special 90 minutes episode on September 19, 2012, and concluded its run on December 19, 2012, with the reunion episode.^[2]

During each Challenge, teams compete in order to become the Power Team, who have the ability to place one team of their decision into the Arena. The other couple going into the Arena is the last placing team of the daily Challenge. Once in the Arena, a team must decide one male-female pair to compete. The losing pair in the Arena go home, and leave their team short two players. Teams can compete with only two players, and have potential to make a greater share of the final's $250,000.^[1][2]

First place wins $250,000, second-place wins $50,000 and third-place wins $40,000.^[1]

Male contestants[3] Original season Finish Frank Sweeney The Real World: San Diego (2011) Winner Zach Nichols The Real World: San Diego (2011) Winner Dustin Zito The Real World: Las Vegas (2011) Runner-up Chet Cannon The Real World: Brooklyn Third place JD Ordoñez The Real World: Brooklyn Third place Derek Chavez The Real World: Cancun Episode 11 Robb Schreiber The Real World: St. Thomas Episode 10 Alton Williams The Real World: Las Vegas (2002) Episode 9 CJ Koegel The Real World: Cancun Episode 8 Ryan Knight The Real World: New Orleans (2010) Episode 7 Trey Weatherholtz The Real World: St. Thomas Episode 6 Preston Charles The Real World: New Orleans (2010) Episode 5 Eric Banks Real World/Road Rules Challenge: Fresh Meat Episode 4/5[a] Brandon Nelson The Challenge: Fresh Meat II Episode 3 Danny Jamieson The Real World: Austin Episode 2 Wes Bergmann The Real World: Austin Episode 1

Female contestants[3] Original season Finish Ashley Kelsey The Real World: San Diego (2011) Winner Sam McGinn The Real World: San Diego (2011) Winner Trishelle Cannatella The Real World: Las Vegas (2002) Runner-up Devyn Simone The Real World: Brooklyn Third place Sarah Rice The Real World: Brooklyn Third place Jonna Mannion The Real World: Cancun Episode 11 Marie Roda The Real World: St. Thomas Episode 10 Nany González The Real World: Las Vegas (2011) Episode 9 Jasmine Reynaud The Real World: Cancun Episode 8 Jemmye Carroll The Real World: New Orleans (2010) Episode 7 Laura Waller The Real World: St. Thomas Episode 6 McKenzie Coburn The Real World: New Orleans (2010) Episode 5 Camila Nakagawa Spring Break Challenge Episode 4/5[a] Cara Maria Sorbello The Challenge: Fresh Meat II Episode 3 Melinda Stolp The Real World: Austin Episode 2 Lacey Buehler The Real World: Austin Episode 1

8 teams of 4 competed in this season of The Challenge. Most teams were formed from Housemates from the same season of The Real World. In a minor twist, the Las Vegas team was composed of two Housemates each from the two Las Vegas-based seasons of The Real World. Additionally (due to the pre-production disqualification of a Real World: Sydney team^[b]), an 8th team consisted solely of Fresh Meat (contestants who debuted on The Challenge) was introduced at the First Challenge.

Team Austin	Team Brooklyn	Team Cancun	Team Fresh Meat[b]	Team Las Vegas	Team New Orleans	Team San Diego	Team St. Thomas
Danny	Chet	CJ	Brandon	Alton	Jemmye	Ashley	Laura
Lacey	Devyn	Derek	Camila	Dustin	Knight	Frank	Marie
Melinda	JD	Jasmine	Cara Maria	Nany	McKenzie	Sam	Robb
Wes	Sarah	Jonna	Eric	Trishelle	Preston	Zach	Trey

• Don't Cross Me: There are four giant beams shaped like two crosses suspended 25 feet above the water, with ladders coming down from the edges. The object is to cross the beams, meet at the center, then climb back down the ladders until all team members reach the markers. If one player falls off the ladder or the beams, that player, along with their teammate on the other side, has to start over at the bottom of the ladder. The team that crosses the beams and climbs down the ladders in the fastest time becomes the power team, while the team with the slowest time is automatically sent to the Arena.^[1]
  • Winner: Team Cancun
• Oil Change: Players from two opposing teams have to wrestle each other out of a square pit filled with olive oil, alternating between male and female. A team wins if one player from the opposing team makes contact with a boundary surrounding the pit. The player that wins the wrestling match collects one of four puzzle pieces needed to complete their team icon, and gets to choose the match for the next round. If nobody wins a watch within a 10-minute time limit, the match ends in a draw with no puzzle pieces earned. The first team to collect four puzzle pieces becomes the power team; however, the challenge continues until the last team that fails to collect all of their puzzle pieces is automatically sent to the Arena.^[7]
  • Winner: Team San Diego
• Hook, Line & Sinker: A platform is suspended from a structure 30 feet above water, and teams have to advance from one side of the platform to the other using metal hooks and foot holds. A team is disqualified if one player falls into the water or does not make it to the end within a 10-minute time limit. The team that makes it to the end of the platform in the fastest time becomes the new power team, while the team with the slowest time is automatically sent to the Arena.^[8]
  • Winner: Team Las Vegas
• Don't Weigh Me Down: Teams have to hold up a large basket attached to a rope from a platform. Each team is split in half — one half of the team is standing atop their designated platform holding up their basket, while the other half runs to a rockpile, and deposits heavy rocks in their opponents' baskets. The players atop the platform have to keep their baskets from touching the ground for as long as possible, while opposing players try to "weigh down" their opponents' baskets with the heavy rocks. The team whose basket touches the ground first is automatically sent to the Arena, while the last team to keep their basket full of rocks from touching ground level wins Power Team.^[9]
  • Winner: Team Cancun
• Chairman of the Board: One member of each team sits on a chair on a platform suspended 30 feet above water. Host T. J. Lavin asks each player a trivia question based on categories like sports, U.S. currency, previous Challenges, Real World seasons, and spelling. At the end of each round, if a player has fallen and still has teammates left, another team member may take their place on the platform. The first team to lose all members is automatically sent to the Arena, while the last team with a player on the platform wins power team. (Note: Trishelle did not participate in this challenge due to dehydration, leaving Team Las Vegas with one less team member.)^[10]
  • Winner: Team San Diego
• Insane Games: This challenge consists of a series of games: "Chariot Race," "Egg Drop," "Ear Pull," a Winner's Playoff and "Fish Head." The team that finishes last in the first two games will compete in a loser's bracket at the end in order to avoid the Arena.
  • "Chariot Race": One guy from each team has to act as a "horse," and pull a sled with his teammates inside the sled. The player pulling the sled has to wear a horse mask, which will make it hard to see, and will require communication from the entire team. Last-place finisher: Team Brooklyn.
  • "Egg Drop": One guy and one girl from each team is chosen to toss eggs over a 10-foot wall. One player on the other side of the wall wears a collar around his/her head (shaped like an oversize funnel), and has to catch the egg in their collar. The first team to catch six eggs in their collar wins. Last-place finisher: Team St. Thomas.
  • "Ear Pull": One player per team sits on a pair of logs, and has to pull a two-foot string from their opponent's ear by only using their own ears and faces. The game in played in same-gender rounds, in a best 2 out of 3. The top two teams advance to a playoff round for a chance to win Power Team. Top two finishers: Team Las Vegas and Team New Orleans.
  • Winner's playoff: Teams Las Vegas and New Orleans compete in a jousting race. Teams approach each other in opposite directions on a track, with a wooden rail in the middle. The riders in the chariot have to knock their opponent off their chariot. The first team to do so wins Power Team.
  • Loser's round - "Fish Head": One player from each team has to knock their opponent off a platform, using a 15-pound fish. The game is played in same-gender rounds. If teams are tied after the first two rounds, a sudden-death round is played, in which T. J. Lavin flips a coin to determine which gender will compete. The losing team is automatically sent to the Arena. Losing team: Team St. Thomas.^[11]
    • Winner: Team New Orleans
• Logged Out: Each team has to solve a simple memory game while hiking up a tall mountain. Each team starts at the foot of the mountain, where the first station shows the 9 pieces that solve the puzzle. They then must hike up to the second station, where there are 13 logs with pictures of the pieces; each team must carry the logs to the top of the mountain and reassemble them in the right position. Everyone must stay together at all times. The first team to get the puzzle right wins Power Team, while the team that fails to complete their puzzle is automatically sent to the Arena.^[12]
  • Winner: Team Brooklyn
• Hunger Games: T. J. Lavin will show each team a food item which must be consumed. Each team will write an estimation of how much of that food item they can eat; the team with the highest estimation will be required to eat said item. If the team fails, they will move onto the loser's round. If the team wins, they will choose another team to enter the loser's round, and their team will advance to the winner's round. A team is disqualified if even one team member vomits. The two losing teams will compete head-to-head to each as much food as possible within two minutes to decide the losing team. The two winning teams will compete head-to-head to each as much food as possible within two minutes to decide the new Power Team, while the team who loses the loser's round is automatically sent to the Arena.^[13]
  • Winner: Team Brooklyn
• Abandon Ship: Teams have to race a life raft from a ship to the shore. First, at least one player has to pull off three buoys from a line resting 25, 20 and 15 feet below the surface of the life raft buoy, which is five feet below the water. After the last buoy is pulled, the life raft immediately inflates above the water, and each team races in their life raft to the shore. A team is given a five-minute penalty is a player does not pull off a buoy before a teammate jumps off the ship into the water. The team that advances their life raft to the shore in the fastest time wins Power Team, while the team with the slowest time is automatically sent to the Arena.^[14]
  • Winner: Team San Diego
• Force Field: Teams have to push each other off a platform that is placed in the center of a mud pit, by using large, inflatable inner tubes. The challenge is played in two different rounds — one for each gender, as well as with a point system, ranging from zero to 80 points. A team is disqualified if they fall down within the platform three times. The first team to be knocked off the platform (during a gender-designated round) will get zero points, while the second, third and fourth teams knocked off receive 20, 40 and 60 points, respectively. The last team standing gets 80 points and wins the round for their team. The same process continues in the second gender-designated round until the team that accumulates the most points in both rounds becomes the new Power Team, while the team that accumulates the fewest combined points is automatically sent to the Arena.^[15]
  • Winner: Team San Diego
• Sling Shot: One player from each team is towed on a launch ramp from a four-wheeler that is driven by their teammate. Once that player is launched into the water, he/she has to swim to a dock in the middle of a lake, ring a bell, then swim back to the shore. Teams with four players will have two timings merged into one. The team with the fastest average time not only becomes the new Power Team, but is also guaranteed a spot in the finals, while the team with the slowest time is automatically sent to the Arena.^[16]
  • Winner: Team Las Vegas
  • Runners-up: Team Brooklyn

There are four games in the Arena: Physical, Mental, Strategy, and Endurance. This game is selected by the Power Team after they reveal their choice to go into the Arena. However, the same game cannot be used more than once until each of the other games have been used.^[1]

• Hall Brawl (Physical): Played in same-gender heat time trial tests, players must run through a narrow hallway past another contestant to ring a bell. The players who ring the bell first in the best two out of three heat time trial tests, wins the elimination.^[1][13]
  • Played by: Cara Maria & Eric vs. Lacey & Wes and Sam & Zach vs. CJ & Jasmine
• Balls Out (Endurance): Players have to slide 25 silver balls over a wall towards their opponents side of the field. The players with the fewest balls on their field wins the elimination.^[7][10][14]
  • Played by: Danny & Melinda vs. Camila & Eric, McKenzie & Preston vs. Chet & Sarah, and Robb & Marie vs. Alton & Nany
• Knot So Fast (Strategy): Players have 10 minutes to create as many knots using feet of rope within a dome-shaped structure. After those 10 minutes are up, players must untie their opponents' knots. The players who untie the other team's knots first wins the elimination.^[8][11][16]
  • Played by: Brandon & Cara Maria vs. Chet & Sarah, Laura & Trey vs. Dustin & Nany and Ashley & Frank vs. Derek & Jonna
• Water Torture (Mental): The guys are hanging from a rope system connected to their female partner by their ankles. The object is for the guys to submerge themselves into a water tank and hold their breath for as long as possible, which pulls the girls up the rope allowing them to solve a memory game. The first team to complete their puzzle wins the elimination.^[9][12][15]
  • Played by: Devyn & JD vs. Eric & Camila, Jemmye & Knight vs. Sam & Zach, and Dustin & Trishelle vs. Robb & Marie

The first phase of the final challenge begins with players from each team parachuting from a plane to ground level on the Namibian desert. Each team then sprints through the desert to their first checkpoint, "Mind Field," in which each team has a 20-minute time limit to align nine numbers on a 3x3 grid to where each number equals 15 in each direction. After a team has correctly aligned the numbers, they can push a red button, which will detonate the designated "mine field" and enable a team to hop aboard a helicopter, which will take them over the mountains to the next checkpoint, "Rung Out." Players from each team must swing a ring roped to a hook toward a pole until one player successfully hooks the ring to the pole. If a player misses, he/she has to take a drink of warm camel milk. The next checkpoint is "Get Tired," in which each team must use multiple poles and ropes in order to carry a series of tires through the desert — for the four-player teams, it is eight tires; for the only two-player team, it is four tires. A helicopter takes each team to the last checkpoint of the first phase, "Camel Nap," in which all but one player from each team must stand within a small designated rectangle in the sand, and supervise a camel overnight in a tent, while one team member gets to sleep by a nearby campfire. A team is assessed a one-minute penalty to begin the second phase of the final challenge if one team member steps out of the rectangle for any reason while supervising the camel. The first team to arrive the "Camel Nap" checkpoint earns a 10-minute headstart, the second-place team earns a five-minute headstart, while the third-place team does not earn a headstart. The teams ride on camels throughout the second phase of the final challenge. After racing through numerous sand dunes on camelback, the first checkpoint of the second phase is "Hallucination Station," in which each team must locate words from a large chart from a distance of 15 feet in order to match an answer key needed to unlock wooden crates that each team will use at the "Sand Shift" checkpoint, in which each team must use the crates to transfer sand into their designated containers several feet away. Once the containers have been filled with sand, the final section is a camel race to the top of a sand dune, with a flag at the end, in which the first-place team wins $250,000, the second-place team wins $50,000, and the third-place team wins $40,000.^[17]

• Winner: Team San Diego

Episode		Winners		Arena contestants								Arena game	Arena outcome
#	Challenge			Last-place		Winners' pick		Last-place pair		Selected pair			Winners		Eliminated
1	Don't Cross Me		Team Cancun		Team Fresh Meat		Team Austin		Cara Maria & Eric		Lacey & Wes	Hall Brawl		Cara Maria & Eric		Lacey & Wes
2	Oil Change		Team San Diego		Team Austin		Team Fresh Meat		Danny & Melinda		Camila & Eric[c]	Balls Out		Camila & Eric		Danny & Melinda
3	Hook, Line & Sinker		Team Las Vegas		Team Fresh Meat		Team Brooklyn		Brandon & Cara Maria[c]		Chet & Sarah	Knot So Fast		Chet & Sarah		Brandon & Cara Maria
4/5	Don't Weigh Me Down		Team Cancun		Team Brooklyn		Team Fresh Meat		Devyn & JD[a]		Camila & Eric	Water Torture		Devyn & JD		Camila & Eric[a]
5	Chairman of the Board		Team San Diego		Team New Orleans		Team Brooklyn		McKenzie & Preston		Chet & Sarah	Balls Out		Chet & Sarah		McKenzie & Preston
6	Insane Games		Team New Orleans		Team St. Thomas		Team Las Vegas		Laura & Trey		Dustin & Nany	Knot So Fast		Dustin & Nany		Laura & Trey
7	Logged Out		Team Brooklyn		Team New Orleans		Team San Diego		Jemmye & Knight		Sam & Zach[c]	Water Torture		Sam & Zach		Jemmye & Knight
8	Hunger Games		Team Brooklyn		Team San Diego		Team Cancun		Sam & Zach		CJ & Jasmine	Hall Brawl		Sam & Zach		CJ & Jasmine
9	Abandon Ship		Team San Diego		Team St. Thomas		Team Las Vegas		Marie & Robb		Alton & Nany	Balls Out		Marie & Robb		Alton & Nany
10	Force Field		Team San Diego		Team Las Vegas		Team St. Thomas		Dustin & Trishelle		Marie & Robb	Water Torture		Dustin & Trishelle		Marie & Robb
11	Sling Shot		Team Las Vegas		Team Cancun		Team San Diego		Derek & Jonna		Ashley & Frank	Knot So Fast		Ashley & Frank		Derek & Jonna
12	Final Challenge		Team San Diego	2nd place: Team Las Vegas; 3rd place: Team Brooklyn

Contestants Episode 1 2 3 4/5[a] 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 Finale Ashley SAFE WIN SAFE SAFE WIN SAFE RISK RISK WIN WIN ELIM WINNER Frank SAFE WIN SAFE SAFE WIN SAFE RISK RISK WIN WIN ELIM WINNER Sam SAFE WIN SAFE SAFE WIN SAFE ELIM ELIM WIN WIN RISK WINNER Zach SAFE WIN SAFE SAFE WIN SAFE ELIM ELIM WIN WIN RISK WINNER Dustin SAFE SAFE WIN SAFE SAFE ELIM SAFE SAFE RISK ELIM WIN SECOND Trishelle SAFE SAFE WIN SAFE SAFE RISK SAFE SAFE RISK ELIM WIN SECOND Chet SAFE SAFE ELIM RISK ELIM SAFE WIN WIN SAFE SAFE SAFE THIRD Devyn SAFE SAFE RISK ELIM RISK SAFE WIN WIN SAFE SAFE SAFE THIRD JD SAFE SAFE RISK ELIM RISK SAFE WIN WIN SAFE SAFE SAFE THIRD Sarah SAFE SAFE ELIM RISK ELIM SAFE WIN WIN SAFE SAFE SAFE THIRD Derek WIN SAFE SAFE WIN SAFE SAFE SAFE RISK SAFE SAFE OUT Jonna WIN SAFE SAFE WIN SAFE SAFE SAFE RISK SAFE SAFE OUT Marie SAFE SAFE SAFE SAFE SAFE RISK SAFE SAFE ELIM OUT Robb SAFE SAFE SAFE SAFE SAFE RISK SAFE SAFE ELIM OUT Alton SAFE SAFE WIN SAFE SAFE RISK SAFE SAFE OUT Nany SAFE SAFE WIN SAFE SAFE ELIM SAFE SAFE OUT CJ WIN SAFE SAFE WIN SAFE SAFE SAFE OUT Jasmine WIN SAFE SAFE WIN SAFE SAFE SAFE OUT Jemmye SAFE SAFE SAFE SAFE RISK WIN OUT Knight SAFE SAFE SAFE SAFE RISK WIN OUT Laura SAFE SAFE SAFE SAFE SAFE OUT Trey SAFE SAFE SAFE SAFE SAFE OUT McKenzie SAFE SAFE SAFE SAFE OUT Preston SAFE SAFE SAFE SAFE OUT Camila RISK ELIM RISK DQ Eric ELIM ELIM RISK QUIT Brandon RISK RISK OUT Cara Maria ELIM RISK OUT Danny RISK OUT Melinda RISK OUT Lacey OUT Wes OUT

Competition

  The contestant's team won the final challenge

  The contestant's team did not win the final challenge

  The contestant was a part of the Power Team, was safe from the Arena, and selected a team to compete in the Arena

  The contestant's team was not selected to go into the Arena

  The contestant's team was nominated for the Arena, but was not selected to compete

  The contestant won in the Arena

  The contestant was eliminated in the Arena

  The contestant withdrew from the Arena

  The contestant was forced to leave the competition after their partner quit from the Arena

No. overall	No. in season	Title	Original air date	US viewers (millions)
281	1	"Tis the Season"	September 19, 2012 (2012-09-19)	1.15
282	2	"The Perks of Being a Rookie"	September 26, 2012 (2012-09-26)	1.23
283	3	"What Happens in Vegas..."	October 3, 2012 (2012-10-03)	1.11
284	4	"The Dark Knight"	October 10, 2012 (2012-10-10)	1.06
285	5	"N-A-R-C-I-S-S-I-S-T-I-C"	October 17, 2012 (2012-10-17)	0.91
286	6	"Going Insane"	October 24, 2012 (2012-10-24)	1.16
287	7	"I Do Not Like You Sam I Am"	November 7, 2012 (2012-11-07)	1.10
288	8	"Honey, I'm Homeless"	November 14, 2012 (2012-11-14)	1.07
289	9	"The Chronicles of Nanyia"	November 28, 2012 (2012-11-28)	1.34[18]
290	10	"A Woman Scorned"	December 5, 2012 (2012-12-05)	0.98[19]
291	11	"I Like to Move it, Move it"	December 12, 2012 (2012-12-12)	0.96[20]
292	12	"Operation Desert Scorn"	December 19, 2012 (2012-12-19)	1.01[21]

The Challenge: Battle of the Seasons Reunion was aired on December 19, 2012, after the season finale. The episode featured Jonny Moseley, one of previous sporadic presenters of the series, who had not previously appeared on The Challenge since its 9th season. The cast members who attended the reunion were: Ashley, Frank, Sam, Zach, Alton, Dustin, Nany, Trishelle, Chet, Devyn, JD, Sarah, Derek, Jonna, Marie & Robb.^[22]

• Official website

37°07′18.3″N 27°19′41.4″E / 37.121750°N 27.328167°E / 37.121750; 27.328167