This page is a signature poll intended to gather useful user feedback and public editor data on Wikipedia:Signatures. The main purpose is to help users determine what other users like or don't like and what works or doesn't work best with signatures on Wikipedia. I created it to help me figure out which variant of my signature I should use, but any user can use this page to make a multiple choice poll of their own since a poll could be a simple vote such as, "Do you like my signature?" Vote: (yes) or (no). For instructions on how to use this page to start your own poll see Starting a poll on the talk page.
Please vote for the variant option you choose below.
- Huggums537 Vote! (guest🖋️book) or (suggestion🗳️box)?
- Huggums537 Vote! (guest🖋️book) or (suggestion🗳️box)?
- Huggums537 Vote! (guest🖋️book) or (suggestion🗳️box)?
- Huggums537 Vote! (guest🖋️book) or (suggestion🗳️box)?
- Huggums537 Vote! (guest🖋️book)🤛vs.🤜(suggestion🗳️box)🤼♂️
- Huggums537 Vote! (guest🖋️book)🤛vs.🤜(suggestion🗳️box)🤼♂️
- Huggums537 Vote! (guest🖋️book)🤛vs.🤜(suggestion🗳️box)🤼♂️
- Huggums537 Vote! (guest🖋️book)🤛vs.🤜(suggestion🗳️box)🤼♂️
- Huggums537voted! (sign🖋️|📞talk) (abridged versions added after voting started)
- Huggums537voted! (sign🖋️|📞talk)
- Huggums537voted! (sign🖋️|📞talk)
- Huggums537voted! (sign🖋️|📞talk)
- Don't like or have comment/suggestion to add in voting section.
Please do not add any variants to the list. Put suggestions in comments. Thanks.
Option 1 or 3 Undecided [With the options having changed, I will wait to see if there is more feedback from the community] because #1 goes well with the text and isn't too off-putting, and by contrast #3 does highlight very well so it would be easy to stand out and find in discussions.Huggums537 Vote! (guest🖋️book) or (suggestion🗳️box)? 15:53, 17 May 2024 (UTC) Option 4 is what I have decided after getting the very helpful feedback from all the participants. 3 Stands out best, and 2 stands out really well too, but it's a little too "cutsie" for my taste. Going with 4. Thanks to everyone who participated. It was very useful to me. Comment updated by Huggums537voted! (guest🖋️book) or (suggestion🗳️box)? on 05:32, 2 June 2024 (UTC) Option 12 is my new favorite. Short and sweet. My apologies to @Panini!, Cosmic6811, Cocobb8, and Volten001: for adding these after voting started. Feel free to change your votes if you so desire. Huggums537voted! (sign🖋️|📞talk) 07:44, 2 June 2024 (UTC)- Option 3 This is a neat idea! I definitely recommend option 3 because the black and yellow don't clash as easily as the blue and pink do. They blend in too much and may be hard to read for some. That being said, I prefer the color blue, so perhaps a lighter variant? Panini! • 🥪 19:45, 18 May 2024 (UTC)
- Panini!, thanks! The one you were calling "pink" was actually brown, and so it got me to wondering what "real" pink would look like and I love it way more than brown so I'm going to modify the poll to show users what real pink looks like since it seems they might think the brown is pink anyway. I also thought lightblue looked great so added that option. You can change your vote if you want to. I think I agree that the brown was not a good option so [just replacing it with the pink]. Huggums537 Vote! (guest🖋️book) or (suggestion🗳️box)? 22:26, 18 May 2024 (UTC)
- I now realize I've really gone and screwed things up by making modifications to the options because future participants are not going to understand what Panini and I are talking about when we're talking about the original "pink"/brown options that I replaced with the "true" pink options listed above so here are those "pink"/brown options that got replaced just so people know which options were replaced and what this discussion is about:
- Huggums537 Vote! (guest🖋️book) or (suggestion🗳️box)?
- Huggums537 Vote! (guest🖋️book)🤛vs.🤜(suggestion🗳️box)🤼♂️ Comment updated on: 17:39, 19 May 2024 (UTC)
- Option 2, 3, or 4 - Option 1&5 are a bit hard to read. -- Cosmic6811 🍁 (T · C) 22:52, 18 May 2024 (UTC)
- Cosmic6811, thanks for participating. The feedback I'm getting is incredibly helpful and I really hope others take advantage of this page to create a poll of their own. Huggums537 Vote! (guest🖋️book) or (suggestion🗳️box)? 00:47, 19 May 2024 (UTC)
- Option 2 is my favourite because it is quite easy to read and makes the text stand out more. Neat idea to conduct a poll for a signature! Cocobb8 (💬 talk • ✏️ contribs) 15:26, 19 May 2024 (UTC)
- Option 4 looks just okay for me.... Tho' anything close to that is also okay(Like Option 8). ~ Volten001 ☎ 03:40, 20 May 2024 (UTC)
- Option 11 - Looks the easiest to read, and is a good length! As someone with partially impaired vision I think 1, 4, 5, 8, 9, and 12 are a tad to hard to read. Additionally, I think 1-8 are a bit too long, but that is just my personal opinion. Indigobeam ♥ 07:29, 18 November 2024 (UTC)
- Option 12 - least disruptive and most visually appealing. JuxtaposedJacob (talk) | :) | he/him | 08:47, 25 November 2024 (UTC)
- Option 10 - Easy to read, and short and concise, meaning that you can find their page or talk page easily.
🍗TheNuggeteer🍗 (My "blotter") 11:10, 3 January 2025 (UTC)
Example poll text: Do you like this/these signature/s? Choose yes/no or vote for your option below.
- -place signature/s here-
Please do not add any variants to the list. Put suggestions in comments. Thanks.
Example poll text: Do you like this/these signature/s? Choose yes/no or vote for your option below.
- -place signature/s here-
Please do not add any variants to the list. Put suggestions in comments. Thanks.
Example poll text: Do you like this/these signature/s? Choose yes/no or vote for your option below.
- -place signature/s here-
Please do not add any variants to the list. Put suggestions in comments. Thanks.